Method of use of sonic hedgehog protein as a ligand for patched

ABSTRACT

The invention relates to hedgehog proteins that are involved in signaling developmental processes. The proteins of the invention modulate differentiation of neural plate. Also provided are methods for identifying compounds that modulate early events in development and more particularly to methods to identify compounds that modulate differentiation of neural plate using hedgehog proteins as ligands for the patched receptor.

RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application claims the benefit of priority under 35 U.S.C. § 119 of Provisional Application No. 60/235,153, filed Sep. 22, 2000, incorporated herein in its entirety.

FIELD OF INVENTION

The invention relates generally to methods for identifying compounds that modulate early events in development and more particularly to methods to identify compounds that modulate differentiation of neural plate using hedgehog proteins as ligands for the patched receptor.

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

The diverse functions of the nervous system, which range from sensory perception and motor coordination to motivation and memory, depend on precise connections formed between distinct types of nerve cells. The development of this complex system occurs in several steps. In vertebrates, first, a uniform population of neural progenitor cells called neural plate cells are recruited from the sheet of ectodermal cells that have not yet committed to a specific pathway of differentiation. Once recruited, neural plate cells rapidly begin to differentiate, acquiring new properties that characterize the cells as immature neurons and glial cells. The first signaling event that allows a single cell type, that is neural plate cells, to give rise to a large number of neuronal and cell types depends on multiple biochemical factors and processes (see, for example, Principles in Neural Science (4th), eds. Kandel, Schwartz and Jessell, Elsevier Science Publishing Company: N.Y., 2000).

The differentiation of the neural plate from uncommitted ectoderm depends on signals secreted by a group of cells called the organizer region. Cells from the organizer region produce factors that induce and suppress development of neural tissues. Mesodermal cells in the organizer region and in the notochord provide an inductive signal that is mediated by a protein called sonic hedgehog. Sonic hedgehog is a member of a family of proteins related to the gene hedgehog (hh). This single protein, acting through short range and long range signaling activities can induce the differentiation of several mature neuronal types: floor plate cells, motor neurons and ventral interneurons.

The hedgehog gene was first identified and isolated in Drosophila where its multiple roles include patterning of larval segments and adult appendages. Vertebrate hh homologues also are involved in many aspects of developmental patterning. Hedgehog protein biogenesis has been best studied for the Drosophila protein but very likely is similar for Hedgehog proteins from all species. After cleavage of an amino-terminal signal sequence on entry into the secretory pathway, the Hh protein undergoes an intramolecular autoprocessing reaction that involves internal cleavage between the Gly-Cys residues of an absolutely conserved Gly-Cys-Phe (GCF) tripeptide. The amino-terminal product of this cleavage, which is the species active in signaling, also receives a covalent cholesteryl adduct. Autoprocessing at this site and covalent linkage to cholesterol have been experimentally confirmed for the Shh protein.

In Drosophila, a hedgehog protein from a construct truncated at the internal site of cleavage is active in signaling, but this protein is not spatially restricted in its signaling activity and therefore causes gross mispatterning and lethality in embryos. The autoprocessing reaction thus is required not only to release the active signal from the precursor but also to specify the appropriate spatial distribution of this signal within developing tissues, presumably through insertion of the cholesteryl moiety into the lipid bilayer of the plasma membrane. Recent studies also have revealed palmitoylation of the amino-terminal cysteine of the amino-terminal signaling domain of the Shh secreted protein (Shh-N); the occurrence of this second lipid modification is regulated by autoprocessing and may also influence the activity and distribution of Shh-N.

Several components have been identified as candidates for receptor function in transduction of the hh protein signal. The patched (ptc) gene, originally identified in Drosophila, encodes a multipass transmembrane protein, a patched receptor (Ptc). ptc mutations in Drosophila embryos cause inappropriate activation of wingless gene expression, a phenotype opposite that of hh mutations, thus suggesting that ptc functions as a negative effector in hh signaling. The observations that hh ptc double mutant embryos resemble ptc mutants and that, in a ptc mutant background, ectopic Hh expression produces no further phenotypic effects, together suggest that the Ptc gene product acts downstream of Hh to regulate its signaling activity. Genetic epistasis studies further suggest that the smoothened gene (smo), which encodes another transmembrane protein (Smo), functions downstream of ptc in the hh signaling cascade. Because smo is required for hh signaling, it has been proposed that Smo activates the Hh pathway and that Ptc inhibits Smo activity. Genetic mosaic analysis in the Drosophila wing imaginal disc showed that Ptc has, in addition to a cell-autonomous negative effect on Hh signaling, an ability to sequester the Hh protein and prevent its movement to adjacent cells.

Vertebrate homologues of both ptc and smo genes have been identified. Shh-N was found to bind to cells expressing Ptc or both Ptc and Smo, but not to cells expressing Smo alone. Moreover, Ptc interacted with Smo independently of the presence of Shh-N, suggesting that the two transmembrane proteins form a complex. An integrated view of Drosophila genetic analyses and biochemical studies of vertebrate homologues suggests a model in which the Ptc-Smo complex might function as Hh receptor, with direct binding of Hh to Ptc releasing Smo activity from inhibition by Ptc. It must be noted, however, that these biochemical studies did not examine the role of a physical interaction between Shh-N and Ptc in activation of the Shh pathway. In addition, these biochemical studies did not exclude the possibility that Shh-N interacts not directly with Ptc but with another component of a complex that includes Ptc, because the crosslinked binding complexes were extremely large and were not analyzed with regard to their composition.

The model just described assumes a role for Shh-N as a ligand for a receptor. The crystal structure of the Shh-N protein, however, suggested an alternative possibility.

This structure revealed a zinc ion coordinated in an arrangement remarkably similar to that of thermolysin, carboxypeptidase A, and other zinc hydrolases. Even more striking is the remarkable similarity in folded structure of a portion of Shh-N to the catalytic domain of D,D-carboxypeptidase from Streptomyces albus, a cell wall enzyme closely related in structure and activity to other bacterial enzymes involved in conferring vancomycin resistance. Although the functional role of this putative hydrolase in Shh-N is not known, one possibility is that signaling requires Shh-N hydrolytic activity on as yet unknown substrates. Thus, several fundamental questions about the mechanisms of Shh-N signaling remain unanswered. To illuminate these issues, the present invention provides Shh-N mutations that abolish zinc hydrolase activity within Shh-N and Shh-N proteins with alterations in evolutionarily conserved surface residues.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF INVENTION

In one embodiment of the invention, there is provided an isolated protein having the amino acid sequence of sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein, wherein alanine is substituted for the amino acid residue at one or more positions selected from position 51, 52, 56, 75, 90, 76, 81, 105, 116, 132, 135, 138, 168, 177, 189 and 195, and combinations of the positions.

In another embodiment of the invention, there is provided an isolated protein including the amino acid sequence set forth in a sequence selected from SEQ ID NO: 1, SEQ ID NO:2, SEQ ID NO:3 SEQ ID NO:4; SEQ ID NO:5, SEQ ID NO:6, SEQ ID NO:8 and SEQ ID NO:12.

In yet another embodiment of the invention, there is provided a method for identifying a compound that modulates a cellular response mediated by a hedgehog protein. The method includes incubating the compound with a cell expressing a hedgehog protein and a patched receptor under conditions sufficient to permit the compound with the patched receptor or the hedgehog protein. A cellular response mediated by a hedgehog protein in the cell incubated with the compound is compared with the response of a cell not incubated with the compound. A difference in response between the cell incubated with the compound and the cell not incubated with the compound is indicative of a compound that modulates a cellular response mediated by the hedgehog protein.

In another embodiment of the invention, there is provided a method for identifying a compound that modulates a cellular response mediated by a patched receptor. The method includes incubating the compound with a cell expressing the patched receptor and a hedgehog protein under conditions sufficient to permit the compound to interact with the cell. The cellular response in a cell incubated with the compound is compared with the cellular response of a cell not incubated with the compound. A difference in response is indicative of a compound that modulates a cellular response mediated by the patched receptor.

In yet another embodiment of the invention, there is provided a method for identifying a compound that modulates differentiation of neural plate cells. The method includes incubating the compound and a hedgehog protein with neural plate cells expressing a patched receptor under conditions sufficient to permit the compound to interact with the cell. The differentiation of neural plate cells incubated with the compound is compared with the differentiation of neural plate cells not incubated with the compound. A difference in differentiation of neural plate cells incubated with the compound compared to differentiation of neural plate cells incubated without the compound is indicative of a compound that modulates differentiation of neural plate cells.

In still another embodiment of the invention, there is provided a method for increasing the stability of a hedgehog protein. The method includes introducing a thiol-containing amino acid into the amino acid of a hedgehog protein. The residue may be introduced at residues 51, 52, 56, 75, 90, 76, 81, 105, 116, 132, 135, 138, 168, 177, 189, 195, or combinations thereof.

In yet another embodiment of the invention, there is provided a method of modifying the pharmacokinetic properties of a hedgehog protein. The method includes introducing into the amino acid sequence of a hedgehog protein a thiol-containing amino acid and modifying the introduced amino acid by attaching a maleimide-linked moiety.

In yet a further embodiment of the invention, there is provided a method of identifying a surface amino acid of a hedgehog protein involved in hedgehog signaling. The method includes incubating a hedgehog protein having one or more substituted amino acid residues and cell expressing a patched receptor under conditions that allow the hedgehog protein to interact with the cell. Hedgehog-mediated signaling is then assayed.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE FIGURES

FIG. 1 shows a likely catalytic site in Shh-N.

FIG. 1A shows a model for an apparent zinc hydrolase catalytic site derived from the crystal structure of Shh-N. Glu-177 and His-135 residues are presumed to be essential for catalysis, and His-141, Asp-148, and His-183 coordinate the Zn²⁺ ion.

FIG. 1B shows superimposed alpha-carbon traces of Shh-N and D,D-carboxypeptidase from Streptomyces albus. The portion of these proteins displaying structural homology is drawn, with the Zn²⁺ ions shown as shaded spheres. Residues within the structurally homologous portion of Shh-N that are altered in SC (four of six) and SD (two of three) are located in structurally diverged loops.

FIG. 1C shows Coomassie blue staining of purified recombinant wild type (WT) and E177A (EA), H135A (HA) and double mutant (EH) Shh-N proteins resolved in SDS/PAGE (15%); molecular mass markers are indicated at left (kDa).

FIG. 1D shows structure-based alignment of amino acid sequence from the portions of mouse Shh (mSHH) and Streptomyces albus D,D-carboxypeptidase (DD-C) shown in FIG. 1B. The residues involved in zinc coordination or hydrogen bonding of the water molecule are shown in dark shading, and other conserved residues are in light shading. Target sites for mutagenesis are indicated for zinc hydrolase mutants and for SC and SD mutants.

FIG. 2 shows direct binding of Shh-N to Ptc.

FIGS. 2A and 2B show Scatchard analysis of the high-affinity component of ³²P-Shh-N binding to EcR-293 cells expressing Ptc (C) or Ptc-CTD (D).

FIG. 2C shows a summary of predicted molecular masses of Ptc and Ptc-CTD, experimental values estimated from Western blotting, and apparent masses of crosslinked products. Experimental values are the average of several independent determinations. Also shown are estimates of the binding coefficients of Shh-N for Ptc and for Ptc-CTD, and estimates of the number of binding sites per cell.

FIG. 3 shows binding of altered Shh-N proteins to Ptc.

FIGS. 3A and 3B show competition by altered proteins for binding of ³²P-Shh-N to EcR-293 cells expressing Ptc-CTD. Binding of ³²P-Shh-N in the presence of each altered protein at various concentrations is normalized to the total value of ³²P-Shh-N bound (approximately 35% of input) in the absence of competitor. The SC mutant, inactive in signaling, also fails to compete for binding to Ptc-CTD. The SE, SF, and SG proteins with intermediate levels of signaling activity, displayed intermediate levels of competition for binding to Ptc-CTD. Data are summarized in Table 1.

FIG. 3C shows signaling activity as a function of Ptc affinity. On the basis of neural plate signaling assays, protein concentrations required for Pax-7 repression are plotted as a function of Ptc-binding affinity. The protein concentrations are plotted as ranges centered about the concentrations presented in Table 1. Note that there is an excellent correlation between Ptc binding and activity in Pax-7 repression. The zinc hydrolase mutants EA, HA, and EH (Table 1) also corroborate this correlation but are omitted for clarity.

FIG. 4 shows the amino acid sequence of sonic hedgehog protein. Autoproteolytic site is double underlined.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

The present invention relates to methods for identifying compounds that modulate developmental processes mediated by hedgehog proteins. Hedgehog proteins, a family of secreted signaling molecules, are involved in pattern formation during embryogenesis. Sonic hedgehog protein, synthesized in the notochord, can induce neural plate cells to differentiate into ventral cell types such as floor plate cells and motor neurons. Differentiation is induced by a hedgehog protein signal that acts through a transmembrane receptor. The interaction of the hedgehog protein and the transmembrane receptor is therefore a key element in modulation of differentiation during development.

The invention provides hedgehog proteins that act as signals in development. As used herein, hedgehog (hh) proteins constitutes a family of secreted signaling molecule s that govern patterns of cellular differentiation during embryogenesis (reviewed in Perrimon, N. (1995) Cell 80, 517-520; Hammerschmidt et al. (1997) Trends Genet. 13, 14-21; and Goodrich and Scott (1998) Neuron 21, 1243-1257). The hedgehog (hh) gene was first identified and isolated in Drosophila, where its multiple roles include patterning of larval segments and adult appendages. Vertebrate hh homologues also are involved in many aspects of developmental patterning. The Sonic hedgehog (Shh) member of this family, for example, is required for patterning of the neural tube and other tissues (Chiang et al. (1996) Nature (London) 383, 407-413).

Hedgehog protein biogenesis (reviewed in Beachy et al. (1997) Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 62, 191-204) has been best studied for the Drosophila protein but very likely is similar for Hedgehog proteins from all species. After cleavage of an amino-terminal signal sequence on entry into the secretory pathway, the Hh protein undergoes an intramolecular autoprocessing reaction that involves internal cleavage between the Gly-Cys residues of an absolutely conserved GCF tripeptide (Lee et al, (1994) Science 266, 1528-1537; and Porter, et al. (1995) Nature (London) 374, 363-366). The amino-terminal product of this cleavage, which is the species active in signaling, also receives a covalent cholesteryl adduct (Porter et al. (1996) Science 274, 255-259). Autoprocessing at this site and covalent linkage to cholesterol have been experimentally confirmed for the Shh protein. In Drosophila, a hedgehog protein from a construct truncated at the internal site of cleavage is active in signaling, but this protein is not spatially restricted in its signaling activity and therefore causes gross mispatterning and lethality in embryos (Porter et al. (1996) Cell 86, 21-34). The autoprocessing reaction thus is required not only to release the active signal from the precursor but also to specify the appropriate spatial distribution of this signal within developing tissues, presumably through insertion of the cholesteryl moiety into the lipid bilayer of the plasma membrane. Recent studies also have revealed palmitoylation of the amino-terminal cysteine of the amino-terminal signaling domain of the Shh secreted protein (Shh-N); the occurrence of this second lipid modification is regulated by autoprocessing and may also influence the activity and distribution of Shh-N (Pepinsky et al. (1998) J. Biol. Chem. 237, 14037-14045).

The signaling domain of the hedgehog protein is the amino terminal domain. As used herein, “amino terminal domain” is an amino acid sequence derived from amino terminal amino acids of a hedgehog protein and having at its carboxy terminus, a glycine-cysteine-phenylalanine (Gly-Cys-Phe) cleavage site specifically recognized by a proteolytic activity of the carboxy terminal fragment of the native hedgehog polypeptide. This fragment is denoted the amino (NH₂)-terminal domain or polypeptide, herein. For example, in the case of mouse sonic hedgehog, the NH₂ domain includes amino acids 34 to 198 of sonic hedgehog protein. The Gly-Cys-Phe cleavage site in mouse hedgehog precursor protein occurs at amino acid residues 198-200 of the full sequence (see FIG. 4). In the case of the Drosophila hedgehog, the amino domain includes amino acids 1-257 of hedgehog protein. The Gly-Cys-Phe cleavage site in Drosophila hedgehog precursor protein occurs at amino acid residues 257-259 of the full sequence Drosophila hedgehog protein. Those of skill in the art will be able to identify the Gly-Cys-Phe cleavage site in other hedgehog proteins, as the amino acid location will be similar and the site will be specifically recognized by the autoproteolytic activity of the corresponding carboxy (COOH) terminal fragment.

The amino-terminal protein is also characterized by being cell-associated in cells expressing the protein in vitro, and being specifically localized in vertebrate or Drosophila cells or embryos. In other words, this amino-terminal fragment of hedgehog, remains close to the site of cellular synthesis. The association of the amino terminal domain with the cell is a result of the processing event that involves lipophilic modification of the amino terminal domain. This modification is initiated by the action of the carboxy terminal domain, generating a thioester intermediate; the carboxy-terminal domain thus does not act simply as a protease, although cleavage of a peptide bond does ultimately result from its action. Specifically, the lipid modification is a cholesterol moiety. In addition, the amino terminal fragment binds to heparin agarose in vitro. The hedgehog protein from which the amino terminal domain is derived includes proteins derived from Drosophila, Xenopus, chicken, zebrafish, mouse, and human.

One exemplary hedgehog amino terminal domain protein is set forth in SEQ ID NO: 1. Sonic hedgehog amino domain protein (Shh-N), formed by amino acid residues 25-198 of precursor sonic hedgehog, is a fragment of a wild type sonic hedgehog protein. As used herein, “wild type” refers to protein sequences as they are found in nature, without manipulation, alteration or modification of the sequence of amino acids. Hedgehog amino terminal proteins are provided in U.S. Pat. No. 6,281,332 Aug. 28, 2001, herein incorporated by reference, in its entirety.

Moreover, it will be generally appreciated that, under certain circumstances, it may be advantageous to provide altered sonic hedgehog protein which function as a hedgehog antagonist, in order to inhibit all or only a subset of the biological activities of the naturally-occurring form of the protein. Thus, specific biological effects can be elicited by treatment with an altered protein, and with fewer side effects relative to treatment with agonists or antagonists which are directed to all of the biological activities of naturally occurring forms of hedgehog proteins.

Proteins contemplated by the present invention include altered sonic hedgehog amino terminal proteins having one or more amino acid substitutions in the sequence of the protein. Altered sonic hedgehog terminal domain proteins have some or all functional properties of wild type sonic hedgehog terminal domain proteins. Such functional properties may be elicited by exposure to altered proteins at concentrations in the range of the concentration of wild type protein, or by concentrations one to ten, to twenty, to thirty orders of magnitude greater than the concentration of wild type protein.

An amino acid substitution refers to the substitution of one amino acid residue for another in the sequence of the protein. In one embodiment of the invention, the amino acid alanine is substituted for the amino acid residue at one or more positions selected from positions 51, 52, 56, 75, 76, 81, 90, 105, 116, 132, 135, 138, 177, 189 and 195.

Exemplary proteins include a sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein having alanine substituted for histidine at position 135 (SEQ ID NO:2), a sonic hedgehog protein having alanine substituted for glutamic acid at position 177 (SEQ ID NO:3), a sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein having alanine substituted for histidine at position 135 and alanine substituted for glutamic acid at position 177 (SEQ ID NO:4), a sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein having alanine substituted for lysine at position 75, alanine for glutamic acid at position 76, alanine for tyrosine at position 81, alanine for aspartic acid at position 105, alanine for asparagine at position 116, alanine for glutamic acid at position 189, and alanine for lysine at position 195 (SEQ ID NO:5), a sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein having alanine for asparagine at position 51, alanine for valine at position 52, alanine for threonine at position 56, and alanine for glutamic acid at position 168 (SEQ ID NO:6), and a sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein having alanine for glutamic acid at position 90, alanine for aspartic acid at position 132, and alanine for glutamic acid at position 138 (SEQ ID NO:8).

Exemplary proteins further include sonic hedgehog amino terminal domain protein wherein the amino acid alanine is substituted for the amino acid residue at one or more positions selected from positions 42, 46, 154, 157, 178 and 179. Exemplary proteins include a sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein having alanine substituted for proline at position 42, alanine substituted for lysine at position 46, alanine substituted for arginine at position 154, alanine substituted for serine at position 157, alanine substituted for serine at position 178 and alanine substitute for lysine at position 179 (SEQ ID NO:7); a sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein having alanine substituted for proline at position 42 and alanine substituted for lysine at position 46 (SEQ ID NO:9); a sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein having alanine substituted for arginine at position 154f and alanine substitute for serine at position 157 (SEQ ID NO:10); and a sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein having alanine substituted for serine at position 178 and alanine substituted for lysine at position 179 (SEQ ID NO:11).

In other embodiments of the invention, there are provided sonic hedgehog amino terminal proteins having a deletion of one or more amino acids from the wild type sequence. For example, a protein having from one to ten amino acids deleted from the amino terminal is contemplated. In one embodiment, a sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein having nine amino acids deleted from the amino terminal of sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein, resulting in a protein comprising amino acids 34 to 198 of wild-type sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein (SEQ ID NO:12) is contemplated by the present invention. Further exemplary “deletion proteins” contemplated by the invention include a sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein having twenty amino acids deleted from the amino terminal of sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein, resulting in a protein having amino acids 45 to 198 of wild-type sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein (SEQ ID NO:13); a sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein having 25 amino acids deleted from the amino terminal of sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein, resulting in a protein having amino acids 50 to 198 of wild-type sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein (SEQ ID NO:14); a sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein having residues 166 to the carboxy terminus deleted resulting a protein having amino acids 25 to 165 of wild-type sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein (SEQ ID NO:15); and a sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein having residues 103 to the carboxy terminus deleted resulting in a protein having amino acids 25 to 101 of wild type sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein (SEQ ID NO:16).

Altered hedgehog amino terminal proteins can be generated by mutagenesis, such as by discrete point mutation(s), or by truncation. For instance, mutation can give rise to proteins which retain substantially the same, or merely a subset, of the biological activity of the hh protein from which it was derived. Alternatively, antagonistic forms of the protein can be generated which are able to inhibit the function of the naturally occurring form of the protein, such as by competitively binding to an hh receptor.

In general, protein referred to herein as having an activity of a hh protein are defined as polypeptides which mimic or antagonize all or a portion of the biological/biochemical activities of a naturally occurring hedgehog protein. Examples of such biological activity include the ability to induce (or otherwise modulate) differentiation of neural plate cells, the ability to modulate the formation and differentiation of the head, limbs, lungs, central nervous system (CNS), digestive tract or other gut components, or mesodermal patterning of developing vertebrate and invertebrate embryos. Hedgehog proteins, especially Shh, can constitute a general ventralizing activity. For instance, the subject protein can be characterized by an ability to induce and/or maintain differentiation of neurons, e.g., motorneurons, cholinergic neurons, dopaminergic neurons, serotonergic neurons, peptidergic neurons and the like. In certain embodiments, the biological activity can comprise an ability to regulate neurogenesis, such as a motor neuron inducing activity, a floor plate inducing activity, a neuronal differentiation inducing activity, or a neuronal survival promoting activity. Hedgehog proteins of the present invention can also have biological activities which include an ability to regulate organogensis, such as through the ability to influence limb patterning, by, for example, skeletogenic activity. The biological activity associated with the hedgehog proteins of the present invention can also include the ability to induce stem cell or germ cell differentiation, including the ability to induce differentiation of chondrocytes or an involvement in spermatogenesis.

The terms “induction” or “induce”, as relating to the biological activity of a hedgehog protein, refers generally to the process or act of causing to occur a specific effect on the phenotype of cell. Such effect can be in the form of causing a change in the phenotype, e.g., differentiation to another cell phenotype, or can be in the form of maintaining the cell in a particular cell, e.g., preventing dedifferentiation or promoting survival of a cell.

The term isolated as used herein also refers to a protein or peptide that is substantially free of cellular material, viral material, or culture medium when produced by recombinant DNA techniques, or chemical precursors or other chemicals when chemically synthesized. The term “substantially pure” as used herein refers to hedgehog amino terminal proteins that are substantially free of other proteins, lipids, carbohydrates, nucleic acids or other materials with which it is naturally associated. One skilled in the art can purify hedgehog proteins using standard techniques for protein purification. The substantially pure protein will yield a single major band on a non-reducing polyacrylamide gel. The purity of the hedgehog protein can also be determined by amino-terminal amino acid sequence analysis.

The invention includes a functional amino terminal hedgehog protein, and functional fragments thereof. As used herein, the term “functional protein” or “functional fragment” refers to a protein that possesses a biological function or activity identified through a defined functional assay and that is associated with a particular biologic, morphologic, or phenotypic alteration in the cell.

Minor modifications of the amino terminal protein amino acid sequence may result in protein which have substantially equivalent activity as compared to the amino terminal protein described herein. Such modifications may be deliberate, as by site-directed mutagenesis, or may be spontaneous.

The amino terminal protein of the invention also includes conservative variations of the polypeptide sequence. The term “conservative variation” as used herein denotes the replacement of an amino acid residue by another biologically similar residue. Examples of conservative variations include the substitution of one hydrophobic residue such as isoleucine, valine, leucine or methionine for another, or the substitution of one polar residue for another, such as the substitution of arginine for lysine, glutamic for aspartic acids, or glutamine for asparagine, and the like. The term “conservative variation” also includes the use of a substituted amino acid in place of an unsubstituted parent amino acid provided that antibodies raised to the substituted polypeptide also immunoreact with the unsubstituted polypeptide.

Also provided by the invention is a method of modifying the pharmacokinetic properties of a hedgehog protein. The method includes introducing into the amino acid sequence of a hedgehog protein a thiol-containing amino acid at position 51, 52, 56, 75, 90, 76, 81, 105, 116, 132, 135, 138, 168, 177, 189, 195, or combinations thereof; and modifying the introduced amino acid by attaching a maleimide-linked moiety. Hedgehog amino terminal proteins can be modified to alter its pharmacokinetic properties. For example, cysteine residues can be introduced at locations away from or distal to the region involved in binding to the patched receptor. Regions not required for binding can be predicted from the altered proteins described herein and by methods known in the art (see, for example, Pepinsdy et al. (2000) J. Biol. Chem. 275:10995-1101, incorporated by reference herein). Such cysteine residues can be specifically targeted by using maleimide-linked moieties, for example to attach polyethylene glycol (PEG) moieties to various positions in the protein without altering properties required for binding to Ptc or for signaling. Modifications to hedgehog proteins alter their pharmacokinetic properties including rendering a hedgehog protein more stable, increasing its ability to bind to proteins, increasing its ability to resist binding to inhibitors or otherwise resist the effects of inhibitory signals, and the like.

Modification of the subject proteins could be effected to alter binding properties of the proteins. For example, HIP-1 is a sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein binding protein. It can interact with sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein and inhibit the activity of sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein. Modification of the altered proteins can be achieved so that sonic hedgehog amino terminal proteins are able to bind to patched receptor and function as a signaling molecule, but they could not bind to HIP-1. This modification can result in a protein that is more active in the presence of HIP-1, e.g., in vivo (see Chuang and McMahon (1999) Nature 18:397:617-21).

The invention includes antibodies immunoreactive with or which bind to hedgehog amino terminal proteins or functional fragments thereof. Antibody which consists essentially of pooled monoclonal antibodies with different epitopic specificities, as well as distinct monoclonal antibody preparations are provided. Monoclonal antibodies are made from antigen containing fragments of the protein by methods well known to those skilled in the art (Kohler, et al., Nature, 256:495, 1975). The term antibody as used in this invention is meant to include intact molecules as well as fragments thereof, such as Fab and F(ab′).sub.2, which are capable of binding an epitopic determinant on hedgehog proteins. The antibodies of the invention include antibodies which bind to the hedgehog amino terminal proteins and which bind with immunoreactive fragments such proteins.

The term “antibody” as used in this invention includes intact molecules as well as fragments thereof, such as Fab, F(ab′).sub.2, and Fv which are capable of binding the epitopic determinant. These antibody fragments retain some ability to selectively bind with its antigen or receptor and are defined as follows:

-   -   (1) Fab, the fragment which contains a monovalent         antigen-binding fragment of an antibody molecule can be produced         by digestion of whole antibody with the enzyme papain to yield         an intact light chain and a portion of one heavy chain; (2)         Fab′, the fragment of an antibody molecule can be obtained by         treating whole antibody with pepsin, followed by reduction, to         yield an intact light chain and a portion of the heavy chain;         two Fab′ fragments are obtained per antibody molecule; (3)         (Fab′)₂, the fragment of the antibody that can be obtained by         treating whole antibody with the enzyme pepsin without         subsequent reduction; F(ab′)₂ is a dimer of two Fab′ fragments         held together by two disulfide bonds; (4) Fv, defined as a         genetically engineered fragment containing the variable         genetically fused single chain molecule. Methods of making these         fragments are known in the art. (See for example, Harlow and         Lane, Antibodies: A Laboratory Manual, Cold Spring Harbor         laboratory, New York (1988), incorporated herein by reference).

As used in this invention, the term “epitope” means any antigenic determinant on an antigen to which the paratope of an antibody binds. Epitopic determinants usually consist of chemically active surface groupings of molecules such as amino acids or sugar side chains and usually have specific three dimensional structural characteristics, as well as specific charge characteristics. It is recognized in the art that antibodies that can distinguish between altered or mutated proteins can be prepared. For example, an antibody that can specifically identify a hedgehog protein having an alanine substitution at position 135 (SEQ ID NO:2) can be prepared.

Antibodies that bind to the hedgehog amino terminal protein of the invention can be prepared using an intact polypeptide or fragments containing small peptides of interest as the immunizing antigen. The protein used to immunize an animal can be derived from translated cDNA or chemical synthesis which can be conjugated to a carrier protein, if desired. Such commonly used carriers which are chemically coupled to the peptide include keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH), thyroglobulin, bovine serum albumin (BSA), and tetanus toxoid. The coupled peptide is then used to immunize the animal (e.g., a mouse, a rat, or a rabbit).

If desired, polyclonal or monoclonal antibodies can be further purified, for example, by binding to and elution from a matrix to which the polypeptide or a peptide to which the antibodies were raised is bound. Those of skill in the art will know of various techniques common in the immunology arts for purification and/or concentration of polyclonal antibodies, as well as monoclonal antibodies (See for example, Coligan, et al., Unit 9, Current Protocols in Immunology, Wiley Interscience, 1991). It is also possible to use the anti-idiotype technology to produce monoclonal antibodies which mimic an epitope. For example, an anti-idiotypic monoclonal antibody made to a first monoclonal antibody will have a binding domain in the hypervariable region that is the “image” of the epitope bound by the first monoclonal antibody.

Monoclonal antibodies of the invention are suited for use, for example, in immunoassays in which they can be utilized in liquid phase or bound to a solid phase carrier. In addition, the monoclonal antibodies in these immunoassays can be detectably labeled in various ways. Examples of types of immunoassays that can utilize monoclonal antibodies of the invention are competitive and non-competitive immunoassays in either a direct or indirect format. Examples of such immunoassays are the radioimmunoassay (RIA) and the sandwich (immunometric) assay. Detection of the antigens using the monoclonal antibodies of the invention can be done utilizing immunoassays that are run in either the forward, reverse, or simultaneous modes, including immunohistochemical assays on physiological samples. Those of skill in the art will know, or can readily discern, other immunoassay formats without undue experimentation.

Monoclonal antibodies can be bound-to many different carriers and used to detect the presence of a hedgehog amino terminal protein. Examples of well-known carriers include glass, polystyrene, polypropylene, polyethylene, dextran, nylon, amylases, natural and modified celluloses, polyacrylamides, agaroses and magnetite. The nature of the carrier can be either soluble or insoluble for purposes of the invention. Those skilled in the art will know of other suitable carriers for binding monoclonal antibodies, or will be able to ascertain such using routine experimentation.

Hedgehog amino terminal proteins may be detected by the monoclonal antibodies when present in biological fluids and tissues. Any sample containing a detectable amount of a hedgehog amino terminal protein can be used. A sample can be a liquid such as urine, saliva, cerebrospinal fluid, blood, serum and the like, or a solid or semi-solid such as tissues, feces, and the like, or, alternatively, a solid tissue such as those commonly used in histological diagnosis.

In performing the assays it may be desirable to include certain “blockers” in the incubation medium (usually added with the labeled soluble antibody). The “blockers” are added to assure that non-specific proteins, proteases, or anti-heterophilic immunoglobulins to anti hedgehog amino terminal protein present in the experimental sample do not cross-link or destroy the antibodies on the solid phase support, or the radiolabeled indicator antibody, to yield false positive or false negative results. The selection of “blockers” therefore may add substantially to the specificity of the assays described in the present invention.

In another embodiment of the invention there is provided a method for identifying a compound that modulates a cellular response mediated by a hedgehog protein. The method includes incubating the compound with a cell expressing a hedgehog protein and a patched receptor under conditions sufficient to permit the compound to interact with the patched receptor, and comparing a cellular response mediated by a hedgehog protein in the cell incubated with the compound with the response of a cell not incubated with the compound. A difference in response between the cell incubated with the compound and the cell not incubated with the compound is indicative of a compound that modulates a cellular response mediated by the hedgehog protein

A “cellular response” as used herein, is an event or sequence of events that singly or together are a direct or indirect response by a cell to a hedgehog protein. Such a cellular response can be modulation of one or more of growth, differentiation, or survival of a cell responsive to hedgehog induction.

A cellular response includes response by neural plate cells. Neural plate cells differentiate into various specific cell types. Both floor plate cells and motor neurons are induced to form from neural plate cells. Accordingly, the cellular response can be an increase or decrease in induction of differentiation of floor plate cells, and an increase or decrease in induction of differentiation of motor neurons.

A cellular response further includes an increase or decrease in repression of a dorsal neural tube cell marker. Concentration-dependent actions of sonic hedgehog in the developing neural tube include suppression of dorsal markers (Pax-3, Gli-3, Ephrin A5), activation of ventral marker genes (HNF3beta, patched, Nkx2.2, netrin-1), and induction of ventral neurons (dopaminergic, serotonergic) and ventrolateral motor neurons (Islet-1+, Islet-2+, HB9+) and interneurons (Engrailed-1+, CHX10+) (Hynes et al (2000) Nat. Neurosci. 3:41-46).

In the vertebrate embryo, the somites arise from the paraxial mesoderm as paired mesodermal units in a craniocaudal sequence. Segmentation is also the underlying principle of the body plan in annelids and arthropods. Genes controlling segmentation have been identified that are highly conserved in organisms belonging to different phyla. Segmentation facilitates movement and regionalization of the vertebrate body; in humans, for example, one can see the results of such regionalization in vertebral bodies, intervertebral disks, ribs, and spinal nerves. Somite research shows that each somite consists of an outer epithelium and a mesenchymal core. Later, the ventral portion of the somite undergoes de-epithelialization and gives rise to the sclerotome, whereas the dorsal portion forms the dermomyotome. The dermomyotome is the source of myotomal muscle cells and the dermis of the back. It also yields the hypaxial muscle buds at flank level and the myogenic cells invading the limb buds. The dorsal and ventral somitic domains express different sets of developmental control genes, for example, those of the Pax family (Brand-Saberi and Christ (2000) Curr. Top. Dev. Biol. 48:1-42) including Pax-1, Pax-3 and Pax -7.

The method can be carried out with hedgehog proteins that mimics the effects of a naturally-occurring hedgehog protein on the cell, as well as with proteins that antagonize the effects of a naturally-occurring hedgehog protein on said cell. Hedgehog proteins contemplated in the practice of the invention include wild-type hedgehog amino terminal protein, and altered hedgehog amino terminal proteins as described herein.

The method includes incubating the compound with a cell expressing a patched receptor (Ptc). The tumor suppressor gene patched (ptc) encodes an approximately 140 kDa polytopic transmembrane protein that binds members of the Hedgehog (Hh) family of signaling proteins and regulates the activity of Smoothened (Smo), a G protein-coupled receptor-like protein essential for hedgehog signal transduction. Ptc contains a sterol-sensing domain (SSD), a motif found in proteins implicated in the intracellular trafficking of cholesterol and/or other cargoes. Cholesterol plays a critical role in hedgehog signaling by facilitating the regulated secretion and sequestration of the hedgehog protein, to which it is covalently coupled. In addition, cholesterol synthesis inhibitors block the ability of cells to respond to hedgehog, and this finding points to an additional requirement for the lipid in regulating downstream components of the hedgehog signaling pathway. Although the SSD of Ptc has been linked to both the sequestration of, and the cellular response to hedgehog, definitive evidence for its function has so far been lacking. It is likely that Ptc controls Smo activity by regulating an intracellular trafficking process dependent upon the integrity of the SDD.

Compounds that modulate a cellular response can include peptides, peptidomimetics, polypeptides, pharmaceuticals, chemical compounds and biological agents. Antibodies and combinatorial compound libraries can also be tested using the method of the invention. One class of chemical compounds includes organic molecules, preferably small organic compounds having a molecular weight of more than 50 and less than about 2,500 Daltons. Candidate compounds comprise functional groups necessary for structural interaction with proteins, for example with a hedgehog amino terminal protein or with a patched receptor, particularly hydrogen bonding, and typically include at least an amine, carbonyl, hydroxyl or carboxyl group, preferably at least two of the functional chemical groups. The candidate compound often comprises cyclical carbon or heterocyclic structures and/or aromatic or polyaromatic structures substituted with one or more of the above functional groups.

The compound may also be a combinatorial library for screening a plurality of compounds. Compounds such as peptides identified in the method of the invention can be further cloned, sequenced, and the like, either in solution of after binding to a solid support, by any method usually applied to the isolation of a specific DNA sequence Molecular techniques for DNA analysis (Landegren et al., Science 242:229-237, 1988) and cloning have been reviewed (Sambrook et al., Molecular Cloning: a Laboratory Manual, 2nd Ed.; Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, Plainview, N.Y., 1998, herein incorporated by reference).

Candidate compounds are obtained from a wide variety of sources including libraries of synthetic or natural compounds. For example, numerous means are available for random and directed synthesis of a wide variety of organic compounds and biomolecules, including expression of randomized oligonucleotides and oligopeptides. Alternatively, libraries of natural compounds in the form of bacterial, fungal, plant and animal extracts are available or readily produced. Additionally, natural or synthetically produced libraries and compounds are readily modified through conventional chemical, physical and biochemical means, and may be used to produce combinatorial libraries. Known pharmacological agents may be subjected to directed or random chemical modifications, such as acylation, alkylation, esterification, amidification, etc., to produce structural analogs. Candidate compounds are also found among biomolecules including, but not limited to: peptides, saccharides, fatty acids, steroids, purines, pyrimidines, derivatives, structural analogs or combinations thereof.

A variety of other agents in addition to those specifically named may be included in the screening assay. These include agents such as salts, neutral proteins, e.g., albumin, detergents, etc. that are used to facilitate optimal protein-protein binding and/or reduce nonspecific or background interactions. Reagents that improve the efficiency of the assay, such as protease inhibitors, nuclease inhibitors, antimicrobial agents and the like may be used. The components are added to the incubation mixture in any order that provides for the requisite binding. Incubations are performed at any suitable temperature, typically between 4 and 40° C. Incubation periods are selected for optimum activity, but may also be optimized to facilitate rapid high-throughput screening. Typically between 0.1 and 10 h will be sufficient.

Also provided by the invention is a method for identifying a compound that modulates a cellular response mediated by a patched receptor. The method includes incubating the compound with a cell expressing the patched receptor and a hedgehog protein under conditions sufficient to permit the compound to interact with the cell and comparing a cellular response in a cell incubated with the compound with the cellular response of a cell not incubated with the compound. A difference in response is indicative of a compound that modulates a cellular response mediated by the patched receptor.

Also provided by the invention is a method for identifying a compound that modulates differentiation of neural plate cells. The method includes incubating the compound and a hedgehog protein with neural plate cells incubates with the compound with the differentiation of neural plate cells not incubated with the compound. A difference in differentiation of neural plate cells incubated with the compound compared to differentiation of neural plate cells incubated without the compound is indicative of a compound that modulates differentiation of neural plate cells.

Also provided by the invention is a method of identifying a surface amino acid of a hedgehog protein involved in hedgehog signaling. The method includes incubating a hedgehog protein having one or more substituted amino acid residues and a cell expressing a patched receptor under conditions that allow the hedgehog protein to interact with the cell; and assaying hedgehog-mediated signaling by the cell. A difference in hedgehog mediated signaling in the cell incubated with the hedgehog protein as compared to hedgehog mediated signaling in a cell not incubated with the hedgehog protein is indicative of a hedgehog protein involved in hedgehog signaling. A surface amino acid of a hedgehog protein is an amino acid that, is on an outer surface of the tertiary or three-dimensional structure of the protein. Such surface amino acids, or their side chains are exposed to interactions with other molecules.

The following examples are intended to illustrate but not to limit the invention in any manner, shape, or form, either explicitly or implicitly. While they are typical of those that might be used, other procedures, methodologies, or techniques known to those skilled in the art may alternatively be used.

Example 1

Preparation of Recombinant Shh-N Mutant Proteins. Constructs for altered Shh-N were made by standard methods (Ausubel et al.(1994) Current Protocols in Molecular Biology (Wiley, New York)). Recombinant proteins were expressed in Escherichia coli and purified as described in Roelink et al. ((1995) Cell 81, 445-455). To prepare the ³²P-labeled Shh-N protein, a protein kinase A site tag (RRASV) was introduced at the carboxy terminus of Shh-N, and the tagged Shh-N was phosphorylated in a reaction containing [γ-³²P]ATP. Cy2-labeled recombinant Shh-N was prepared by using CyDye FluoroLink Reactive Dye (Amersham).

Chicken Neural Plate Explant Culture Chicken intermediate neural plate explant culture methods have been described in Roelink et al (1995, supra) and Cooper et al. ((1998) Science 280, 1603-1607). Neural plate explants were stained with either mouse anti-Pax-7 [PAX7, Developmental Studies Hybridoma Bank (DSHB)], rabbit anti-hepatocyte nuclear factor (HNF)-3β (K2, a gift from T. M. Jessell, Columbia University), or mouse anti-Islet-1(40.2D6, DSHB) antibodies.

Cell Culture for Ptc Expression Fragments encoding full-length mouse Ptc and carboxyl-terminal Myc-tagged Ptc-CTD (Ptc with a truncation resulting in a 140-residue carboxyl-terminal deletion; amino acids nos. 1-1,291, a gift from M. P. Scott, Stanford University) were inserted into pIND(Sp) vector (Invitrogen). To make stable cell lines, EcR-293 cells (Invitrogen) were transfected with recombinant constructs or empty vector, and several independent clones for each construct were isolated.

Shh-N-Ptc-Binding Assay. Ptc expression was induced in cloned stable derivatives of the cell line EcR-293 by addition of ponasterone A (Invitrogen). After induction, 2.5×10⁵ cells were mixed with increasing concentrations (0.1 nM-50 nM) of ³²P-Shh-N (for Scatchard analyses) or with a fixed concentration (0.9 nM) of ³²P-Shh-N and various concentrations of competitors (for competitive binding assays). After incubation at 4° C., cells were collected, and the bound ³²P-Shh-N was determined. For the qualitative Ptc-binding assay, QT6 cells transiently transfected with pRK5-Ptc-CTD were incubated with 2 nM Cy2-labeled Shh-N protein and 160 nM unlabeled competitor. The ability of the unlabeled protein to compete for binding of Cy2-Shh-N protein to cells was directly observed by fluorescence microscopy.

Crosslinking of 32P-Shh-N to Ptc. Induced EcR-293 cells were incubated with the ³²P-labeled Shh-N at a final concentration of 2 nM at 4° C. Unlabeled Shh-N was added as competitor to 200 nM. After the cells were washed once with PBS, labeled Shh-N was crosslinked to cells by adding freshly prepared disuccinimidyl suberate (Pierce) to 5 mM in PBS and incubating for 50 min. at 4° C. Crosslinked cells were washed with cold PBS and lysed in 0.15 mM NaCl/0.05 mM Tris-HCl, pH 7.2/1% Triton X-100/1% sodium deoxycholate/0.1% SDS (RIPA) buffer containing proteinase inhibitors. Lysate proteins were fractionated by SDS/PAGE (6%) and visualized by staining with Coomassie blue. After the gel was dried, crosslinked products were visualized by autoradiography.

Example 2 Zinc Hydrolase Activity is Not Required for Shh-N Signaling

To determine whether Shh-N acts as an enzyme, glutamate-177 (E177) and histidine-135 (H135) were substituted by alanine. E177 forms a hydrogen bond to a zinc-bound water molecule, and H135 is positioned to stabilize a potential tetrahedral intermediate (FIG. 1A; Hall et al. (1995) Nature (London) 378, 212-216). By analogy with other zinc hydrolases, both residues are likely to be essential for catalytic activity (Christianson, D. W. (1991) Adv. Protein Chem. 42, 281-355). Furthermore, the VanX protein, a structural homologue of Shh-N, displays a reduction in activity of more than six orders of magnitude on alteration of the R71 residue (Lessard and Walsh (1999) Chem. Biol. 6, 177-187), which corresponds to H135 in Shh-N (Bussiere et al., (1998) Mol. Cell 2, 75-84). These substitutions (E177A, H135A) were introduced individually and in combination into an E. coli expression vector, and purified altered proteins were prepared (FIG. 1C).

A chicken intermediate neural plate explant culture system was used to test the signaling activity of recombinant proteins (Roelink et al. (1995) supra). Wild-type Shh-N protein applied to these explants induced motor neurons at 5 nM and predominantly floor plate cells at 25 nM, as monitored by expression of Islet-1 and HNF-3 , respectively. Shh-N protein at 4 nM sufficed for suppression of the dorsal marker Pax-7. The concentrations of Shh-N required for these inductive events, although slightly higher than previously reported (Roelink et al. (1995) supra; Ericson et al. (1997) Cell 90, 169-180; and B27 Cooper et al.(1998) supra), were reproducible in the assay protocol used in this study.

Signaling activities of Shh-N zinc hydrolase mutants were studied in chicken intermediate neural plate explants double stained for expression of the motor neuron marker Islet-1 and the floor plate marker HNF-3β. No Islet-1- or HNF-3β-positive cells were observed in control explants, whereas 5 nM and 25 nM concentrations of wild-type Shh-N induced expression of Islet-1 and HNF-3β. Explants cultured with medium only express Pax-7 but not HNF-3β. Wild-type Shh-N protein fully repressed expression of Pax-7 at 4 nM and uniformly induced HNF-30 in all cells at 20 nM. The EH and EA mutant proteins repressed Pax-7 at 4, albeit somewhat less efficiently, and were able to uniformly induce HNF-3β expression at 20. The H135A (HA) mutant protein was indistinguishable from wild type at 4 nM and at 20 nM.

All three of the zinc hydrolase mutant Shh-N proteins tested, E177A (EA), H135A (HA), and the double mutant (EH), retained the capacity to repress Pax-7 expression and to induce floor plate cells in the explants. Whereas the EA and EH mutant proteins displayed slightly reduced signaling activity, the HA protein was indistinguishable from wild type (Table 1). Because the altered residues are absolutely critical for catalytic activity in other zinc hydrolases (Christian (1991) supra; and Lessard and Walsh (1999) supra), retention of signaling activity by Shh-N hydrolase mutant proteins indicates that catalytic activity is not required for signaling. The reduced potency for EH and EA in signaling may reflect a destabilization of folded protein structure, as might be expected from substitution of Ala for the largely buried side chains of the Glu-177 and His-135 residues. Indeed, the EA and EH altered proteins displayed a somewhat reduced affinity for Ptc-CTD protein, which may account for their reduced potency, whereas HA was essentially indistinguishable from wild type (Table 1; see below). TABLE 1 Pax-7 HNF-3β Ptc-CTD repression, induction, affinity, Heparin Protein Mutation sites nM nM nM 5E1 IP Binding WT Wild type (aa 25-198) ˜4 ≦20 0.48 ++ + HA H135A ˜4 ≧20 0.63 ND + EA E177A ˜10 ≧20 1.7 ND + EH H135A, E177A ˜10 ≧20 1.7 ND + SA K75A, E76A, Y81A, D105A, ˜4 ≦20 0.66 ++ + N116A, E189A, K195A SB N51A, V52A, T56A, E168A ˜4 ≧20 0.48 ++ + SC P42A, K46A, R154A, S157A, >>1,000 >>1,000 >>36 − − S178A, K179A SD E90A, D132A, E138A ˜10 ≧20 0.84 ++ + SE P42A, K46A ˜20 ˜100 2.4 + + SF R154A, S157A ˜70 ≧100 9.1 + + SG S178A, K179A ˜30 ˜100 4.3 + +

Protein signaling was tested at initial concentrations of 4, 20, 100, 500, and 1,000 mM and subsequently at 10 nM concentration intervals for EA, HA, EH, SD, SE, SF, and SG (Table 1). The minimum concentration required for complete repression of Pax-7 and for uniform induction of HNF-3β is shown for each protein. As an indication of affinity for Ptc-CTD, binding coefficients (K₁) for binding of mutant Shh-N proteins to Ptc-CTD were derived from competitive binding experiments in FIG. 3A and B by using the equation K₁=[IC₅₀]/(1+[L]/K_(L)), where [IC₅₀] is the concentration of unlabelled mutant proteins required for 50% competition. [L] is the concentration of unbound wild-type protein (³²p-Shh-N) and K_(L) is the dissociation constant for wild-type Shh-N. Immunoprecipitation by 5E1 monoclonal antibody and binding to heparin-agarose are indicated. ND, not determined.

Alterations in residues that should be critical for the putative zinc hydrolase activity of Shh-N did not disrupt its ability to induce ventral neural cell types or to suppress dorsal markers, suggesting that catalytic activity is not required for Shh signaling in the neural plate. Although residues constituting the putative zinc hydrolase active site are widely conserved among Hh family members, they are not fully conserved in Drosophila suggesting that hydrolase function is not required for signaling in this organism. We also introduced and ectopically expressed the El77A and EH mutant Shh constructs into Drosophila and compared their ability to mispattern the embryonic cuticle with that of wild-type Shh and could detect no significant difference between them (H. E. F. Takahashi and P.A.B., unpublished data), further substantiating dispensability of catalytic activity for Shh-N signaling function in the context of developing Drosophila embryos. Furthermore, experiments with mutant proteins expressed in cultured cells suggest that the putative hydrolase activity is not required for the normal biogenesis and processing of Shh, nor for its normal state of modification. It is also noted that no hydrolase activity of Shh-N in biochemical assays with a variety of substrates was detected, including some like those for D,D-carboxypeptidase, which contained D-amino acid residues.

The putative zinc hydrolase of Shh-N has thus resisted our attempts to reveal an activity, either in biochemical or in in vitro or in vivo signaling assays, raising the possibility that the putative catalytic site represents an evolutionary vestige of its common ancestry with the D,D-carboxypeptidase family of proteins. In this view, the zinc atom may have lost its ancestral role in catalysis but could have retained a role in stabilizing protein structure through interactions with the side chains of coordinating residues. The lack of conservation of coordinating residues in the Drosophila protein may indicate a replacement of these interactions by other stabilizing interactions. General dispensability of hydrolase activity in Hh signaling is consistent with the importance of surface residues conserved among Hh proteins for binding to Ptc and for signaling (see below). Alternatively, it is possible that Shh-N hydrolase retains a role not detected by our biochemical or in vitro and in vivo signaling assays. Such a role likely would be modulatory in nature, given the essentially normal signaling activity of hydrolase mutant proteins, and its discovery may require targeted recombination to mutagenize the endogenous mouse Shh gene.

Example 3 Direct Binding of Shh-N Protein to Ptc

Because the analyses above suggested a noncatalytic function of Shh-N protein, experiments next focused on Shh-N interaction with Ptc (Stone et al. (1996) Nature (London) 384, 129-134; and B22 Marigo et al. (1996) Nature (London) 384, 176-179). To determine whether Shh-N protein directly interacts with Ptc, stable cloned EcR-293 cell lines were generated for ecdysone-inducible expression of full length Ptc and Ptc-CTD (see Example 1). Such stable cell lines, but not a control line carrying the empty vector, expressed Ptc and Ptc-CTD proteins when induced with the ecdysone analog, ponasterone A. On protein blots probed with anti-Ptc antibody, two broad bands were detected for Ptc (dots, 168 kDa and 157 kDa) or for Ptc-CTD (dots, 163 kDa and 141 kDa). The estimated masses of the faster-migrating species were close to the molecular masses predicted from primary sequence (159 kDa for Ptc and 144 kDa for Ptc-CTD) (FIG. 2C).

For sensitive detection of Shh-N binding to Ptc, a ³²P-labeled Shh-N protein was prepared by introducing a protein kinase A (PKA) site at the carboxy terminus of Shh-N followed by labeling of the purified recombinant protein with PKA and γ-³²P]ATP. Ptc and Ptc-CTD expression was examined in stably transfected cloned cell lines. Cell lysates were prepared from′ stable EcR-293 cell lines carrying pIM(Sp) (empty vector control), pIND(Sp)-Ptc, or pIND(Sp)-Ptc-CTD, and proteins were fractionated by SDS/PAGE (6%) followed by blotting and detection with anti-Ptc antibody (Santa Cruz Biotechnology). Two bands (dots) were detected in lysates from Ptc or from Ptc-CTD cells, but not from control cells. Crosslinking of ³²P-labeled Shh-N protein to Ptc and Ptc-CTD. EcR-293 cells expressing Ptc and Ptc-CTD were incubated with ³²P-Shh-N protein in absence (−) or presence (+) of a 100-fold excess of unlabeled Shh-N protein and then crosslinked. Cell lysates were subjected to SDS/PAGE (6%) and crosslinked products detected by autoradiography. Autoradiographic images for control and Ptc and for Ptc-CTD are presented at distinct contrast settings to highlight the crosslinked species. Addition of this kinase site at the carboxy terminus did not affect signaling activity of Shh-N. Crosslinking of ³²P-labeled Shh-N protein to EcR-293 cells expressing Ptc or Ptc-CTD was performed in the presence of a bivalent crosslinker, disuccinimidyl suberate. Crosslinked products were detected in lysates of Ptc and Ptc-CTD cells, but not in those of control cells. These crosslinked species were abolished by competition with unlabeled Shh-N protein, demonstrating a specific interaction. The crosslinked species form a single band, not two as detected in Western blotting, suggesting that a particular form of Ptc or Ptc-CTD might bind to Shh-N. The estimated molecular masses of the crosslinked products (172 kDa for Ptc and 158 kDa for Ptc-CTD) differ by 14 kDa, which corresponds closely to the differences in mass between Ptc and Ptc-CTD and definitively indicates the participation of Ptc and Ptc-CTD in these complexes. The apparent masses of these complexes furthermore are close to the sums of the masses of Shh-N plus Ptc or of Shh-N plus Ptc-CTD (178 kDa and 163 kDa, respectively) (FIG. 2C), suggesting a 1:1 stoichiometry of Ptc and Shh-N in these complexes. These results strongly suggest that Shh-N interacts directly with Ptc protein.

Quantitative analysis of ³²P-Shh-N binding to these cells revealed a high-affinity Ptc-dependent component of binding that could be competed by nanomolar concentrations of unlabeled Shh-N and a low-affinity component that was not dependent on Ptc expression and that could not be competed by Shh-N. Scatchard analysis of the Ptc- and Shh-N-specific high affinity component (FIGS. 2A and 2B) indicated that the binding coefficients of Ptc and Ptc-CTD for ³²P-Shh-N protein are similar (0.58 nM and 0.48 nM respectively; FIG. 2C). Assuming, as argued above, that one Shh-N ligand binds to one Ptc molecule, the number of binding sites per cell for Ptc-CTD (210,000) is about 5.5 times higher than that for Ptc (38,000) (FIG. 2C). The temperature utilized in these binding studies (4° C.) is not permissive of endocytosis, indicating that Shh-N binding initially occurs on the cell surface, even though immunofluorescence studies clearly demonstrate that Ptc and Ptc-CTD proteins are predominantly localized inside cells. The difference in number of binding sites for these two proteins thus could be caused either by a higher degree of surface localization for Ptc-CTD or, alternatively, by a higher level of Ptc-CTD expression as compared with Ptc, a phenomenon also consistently observed in transiently transfected. Thus, at present one cannot distinguish whether the 140 residues absent from Ptc-CTD influence the subcellular localization of the Ptc protein or its steady-state levels within the cell.

Example 4 The Role of Shh-N Surface Residues in Signaling and in Ptc Binding

Having demonstrated a direct and high-affinity interaction between Ptc and Shh-N, the significance of this interaction was determined by examining the correlation between Ptc binding and signaling potency of altered Shh-N proteins. The Shh-N protein was subjected to systematic mutagenesis to identify surface residues involved in signaling and potential ligand/receptor interactions. Because Hh proteins can act similarly across species and in distinct biological settings [Shh, for example, is active in Drosophila (Chang et al. (1994) Development (Cambridge, U.K) 120, 3339-3353; and Krauss et al. (1993) Cell 75, 1431-1444) and distinct vertebrate proteins can act in common pathways (Ekker et al. (1995) Development (Cambridge, U.K) 121, 2337-2347)], it seems likely that surface residues potentially important in inductive activities and ligand/receptor interactions would be conserved. The Shh-N structure was used to identify surface residues based on degree of side chain exposure to solvent (Hall et al. (1995) supra). Among these surface residues, those that are evolutionarily conserved were geographically divided into four major regions named SA, SB, SC, and SD and subjected to mutagenesis. Four mutant proteins were generated, each containing multiple alanine substitutions at the conserved surface residues within each region (see Table 1). Because the side chains of the residues selected are solvent exposed, it was expected that the folded structures of these proteins would not be affected.

The altered proteins were purified and applied to chicken neural plate explant cultures. The SA and SB altered proteins repressed Pax-7 expression and induced floor plate cells in the explants as well as the wild-type protein, and the SD altered protein displayed an approximate 2.5-fold reduction in activity. In striking contrast, no signaling activity of the SC mutant could be detected even at 1 μM, a concentration 250-fold higher than that required for Pax-7 repression by wild-type protein (results summarized in Table 1). Ptc binding for these altered proteins was next examined using a competition binding assay. The SA, SB, and SD mutant proteins competed with the ³²P-labeled wild-type Shh-N protein for binding to Ptc-CTD expressing cells as well or nearly as well as the wild-type protein (FIG. 3A), yielding similar binding coefficients (Table 1). Ptc-binding activity of the SC mutant, however, was not detectable (FIG. 3A; Table 1), suggesting a possible correlation between Ptc binding and signaling activity for the Shh-N protein.

To explore this correlation further, three additional proteins (SE, SF, and SG) were tested, each with alterations in two amino acid residues that comprise distinct subsets of the six residues altered in SC (see Table 1). All three of these mutant proteins displayed signaling activity in the explant culture assay, but only at significantly reduced levels. At 4 nM none of these three proteins repressed Pax-7; at 20 nM the SE and SG proteins repressed Pax-7 almost completely or partially, respectively, but SF did not. At 100 nM, the SE and SG proteins induced HNF-3β expression in most cells of the explant, but SF did so only in a small number of cells. Further assays at concentration intervals of 10 nM pinpointed the minimal concentrations required for Pax-7 repression, with values of about 20, about 30, and about 70 nM for SE, SG, and SF, respectively (results in Table 1). Competition binding assays also revealed a significantly reduced affinity of the SE and SG proteins for Ptc-CTD, and an even lower affinity for the SF protein (FIG. 3B; Table 1). These results indicate that normal Ptc binding and neural plate signaling activities require distinct contributions from multiple individual residues in the SC surface region. Furthermore, among proteins with alterations in distinct subsets of the SC mutant residues, Ptc-binding affinity correlated extremely well with neural plate signaling activity (FIG. 3CC).

Shh-N proteins with deletions of amino- or carboxyl-terminal residues were also purified and their activities qualitatively in signaling and in Ptc binding were examined (Table 2). An altered protein lacking nine amino-terminal residues ΔN34) displayed signaling and Ptc-binding activities indistinguishable from wild type. In contrast, ΔN50, which lacks 25 amino-terminal residues, completely lost both activities. It was noted that the residues deleted in ΔN50 include P42 and K46, which were altered in the SC and SE mutant proteins, and that the mutant ΔN45 (lacking 20 amino-terminal residues), which does not contain P42, also lost signaling activity. The activity defects in these proteins are more severe than those of the SE protein, suggesting that loss of these amino-terminal residues may have some effect on the overall structure or stability of the Shh-N protein. A deletion mutant lacking residues from 166 to the carboxy terminus, ΔC 165, had neither signaling nor Ptc-binding activities, and ΔC101 also lost signaling activity (Table 2). These deletions also remove residues that are altered in the SC protein (R154, S157, S178, and K179 in ΔC101 ; S178 and K179 in ΔC165), but again, the deleted regions are sufficiently extensive that they would be expected to affect protein structure. TABLE 2 Residues HNF-3β Ptc-CTD Heparin Protein present induction binding 5E1 IP binding WT wild type + + + + (aa 25-198) ΔN34 aa 34-198 + + + + ΔN45 aa 45-198 − ND ND − ΔN50 aa 50-198 − − − − ΔC165 aa 25-198 − − − + ΔC101 aa 25-101 − ND ND +

The properties of the mutant proteins (Table 2) were either indistinguishable or completely different from wild type in a qualitative neural plate assay for induction of HNF3 P or in a qualitative Ptc-binding competition assay using Qt6 cells transiently transfected with Ptc-CTD and Cy2-labeled sonic hedgehog amino terminal protein. Immunoprecipitation by 5E1 monoclonal antibody and binding to heparin agarose are indicated. ND indicates not determined.

In all of the altered proteins tested not a single example of a protein that retained signaling activity while losing the ability to bind Ptc was found. As seen in FIG. 3C, there is an excellent correlation between Ptc binding and signaling activity in all altered proteins for which these properties can be measured, and these results strongly suggest that Ptc binding may be a critical requirement for signaling.

Previous genetic and biochemical studies are consistent with the idea that Ptc may function as a Hh receptor. The biochemical analyses demonstrated that Shh-N protein binds to Ptc-expressing cells, that Ptc is coimmunoprecipitated with Shh-N and vice versa, and that Ptc can be crosslinked in a complex containing Shh-N. Because the composition of the crosslinked complexes was not characterized, however, these studies could not exclude the possibility that instead of binding directly to Ptc, Shh-N may bind to another component of a complex that includes Ptc. These biochemical studies also did not examine the role of such an interaction in the activation of the Shh pathway. The latter is a particularly significant issue given the genetically demonstrated role of Ptc in sequestration of Hh protein to restrict its movement within Drosophila tissues.

In addressing these questions, a crosslinked product containing radiolabeled Shh-N was identified that is specifically competed by unlabeled Shh-N but not by the unlabeled mutant SC protein. This crosslinked complex also contains Ptc because its formation depends on Ptc expression and because it displays an apparent molecular mass difference that corresponds closely to the differences between full-length Ptc or Ptc-CTD. Finally, for both Ptc molecules, the apparent mass of the complex is close to the sum of Shh-N plus Ptc. Thus, although direct binding ideally would be demonstrated by studies with purified components, the properties of our crosslinked complexes strongly suggest a direct association between Shh-N and Ptc with a probable stoichiometry of 1:1. Given the possible anomalies in migration of such crosslinked species, we cannot rule out the possibility that more than one Shh-N molecule is present in these complexes, nor can we distinguish between the participation of the slower- or faster-migrating Ptc forms, which probably differ in their glycosylation. Although it has been reported that Ptc interacts with Smo independently of Shh-N, the apparent masses of our crosslinked products would appear to exclude Smo, which has a predicted mass of 87 kDa. It is possible that the cells utilized in the present study do not express Smo endogenously or that high-level expression of Smo is required for formation of a complex with Ptc/Shh. Alternatively, the experimental conditions for crosslinking might disrupt Ptc-Smo interaction or fail to capture Smo protein.

Also identified herein, using altered Shh-N proteins, is the region of the Shh-N protein surface that is involved in Ptc binding. These altered proteins have been used to show that neural plate signaling activity is retained in proportion to the binding affinity for Ptc. Thus, the extensive alterations in surface residues of the SA, SB, and SD proteins do not affect or only mildly affect Ptc binding, and these proteins retain normal or nearly normal signaling activity. At the other extreme, the SC altered protein displays a complete loss of Ptc binding, and this is reflected in a complete loss of neural plate signaling activity. Even more telling, proteins carrying distinct subsets of the residues altered in SC result in intermediate levels of Ptc-binding activity and corresponding intermediate levels of neural plate signaling activity (FIG. 3C). Multiple individual residues within the SC surface region that contribute independently to Ptc binding thus also similarly contribute to signaling potency. Although our results cannot exclude a role for interactions with other proteins in reception of the Shh signal, they do strongly suggest that direct binding to Ptc is a critical step, and this information will serve as the basis for further elucidation of downstream events.

Example 5 Antibody Recognition and Heparin Binding of Altered Proteins

The monoclonal antibody 5E1, directed against Shh-N, blocks signaling in neural plate explants (Ericson et al (1996) Cell 87, 661-673) and also blocks binding of the Shh-N protein to Ptc-expressing cells. The reactivity of the 5E1 antibody with altered Shh-N proteins was examined by immunoprecipitation. All proteins that retain signaling and Ptc-binding activities, including wild type, SA, SB, SD, and AN34, also retain full reactivity with 5E1 (Tables 1 and 2). In contrast, the altered proteins SC, ΔN50, and ΔC165, which lost both signaling and Ptc-binding activities, were not immunoprecipitated by 5E1 (Tables 1 and 2). Altered proteins with intermediate signaling and Ptc-binding properties, such as SE, SF, and SG, displayed intermediate reactivities with 5E1 (Table 1). Reactivity of 5E1 with Shh-N proteins thus correlates well with Ptc binding and neural plate signaling activities.

Because 5E1 works well for immunoprecipitation and for immunocytochemistry but very poorly in Western analysis, it appears to recognize an epitope present on the native Shh-N protein but not in denatured protein. The strong correlation between 5E1 binding, Ptc binding, and neural plate signaling furthermore suggests that the 5E1 epitope coincides with determinants required for these activities. One possible explanation for the coordinate loss of signaling, 5E1 binding, and Ptc binding in the SC protein is that the folded structure of this protein might be disrupted. Circular dichroism analysis, however, indicates that the secondary structure profile of SC is similar to that of wild-type Shh-N, suggesting that any disruption in folded structure must be highly local in nature. In addition, mutations in distinct subsets of the residues altered in SC display intermediate phenotypes, suggesting multiple independent contributions of individual residues in formation of the Ptc-interacting region of the protein surface.

The Shh-N protein also binds to heparin, and the crystal structure contains a sulfate anion at a location near the SC region. In addition, recent evidence suggests that tout velu, a Drosophila gene whose mammalian homologues function in the polymerization of glycosamines for synthesis of heparan sulfate proteoglycans (McCormick et al. (1998) Nat. Genet. 19, 158-161; and Lind et al. (1998) J. Biol. Chem. 273, 26265-8), plays a role in the reception and transport of the Hh signal (Bellaiche et al. (1998) Nature (London) 394, 85-88). Therefore tests were conducted to determine whether the alterations in these proteins affect their ability to bind to heparin agarose. As seen in Tables 1 and 2 only three of the proteins tested, SC, ΔN45, and ΔN50, lost the ability to bind heparin agarose, and these three proteins are completely inactive in Ptc binding and signaling. Some of the proteins that lose signaling and Ptc-binding activity retained the ability to bind heparin, indicating that heparin binding is not sufficient for Ptc binding and for signaling. These data, however, would be consistent with the idea that heparin binding may be necessary for Ptc binding and for signaling.

While the invention has been described in detail with reference to certain preferred embodiments thereof, it will be understood that modifications and variations are within the spirit and scope of that which is described and claimed. 

1. An isolated protein comprising the amino acid sequence set forth in SEQ ID NO:1 wherein alanine is substituted for the amino acid residue at a position selected from 51, 52, 56, 75, 90, 76, 81, 105, 116, 132, 135, 138, 168, 177, 189 and 195, and any combination thereof.
 2. An isolated protein comprising the amino acid sequence set forth in a sequence selected from SEQ ID NO:1, SEQ ID NO:2, SEQ ID NO:3, SEQ ID NO:4, SEQ ID NO:5, SEQ ID NO:6, SEQ ID NO:8 and SEQ ID NO:12. 3-46. (canceled)
 47. The isolated protein of claim 1, wherein at least one thiol-containing amino acid is substituted at a position corresponding to position 51, 52, 56, 75, 90, 76, 81, 105, 116, 132, 135, 138, 168, 177, 189 and 195, and any combination thereof, and wherein the protein is modified by attachment to a maleimide-linked moiety.
 48. The isolated protein of claim 47, wherein the thiol-containing amino acid is cysteine or methionine.
 49. The isolated protein of claim 47, wherein the maleimide-linked moiety is a polyethylene glycol (PEG) moiety.
 50. The isolated protein of claim 2, wherein at least one thiol-containing amino acid is substituted at a position corresponding to position 51, 52, 56, 75, 90, 76, 81, 105, 116, 132, 135, 138, 168, 177, 189 and 195, and any combination thereof, and wherein the protein is modified by attachment to a maleimide-linked moiety.
 51. The isolated protein of claim 50, wherein the thiol-containing amino acid is cysteine or methionine.
 52. The isolated protein of claim 50, wherein the maleimide-linked moiety is a polyethylene glycol (PEG) moiety.
 53. An isolated protein comprising the amino acid sequence set forth in a sequence selected from SEQ ID NO:7, SEQ ID NO:9, SEQ ID NO:10, and SEQ ID NO:11.
 54. The isolated protein of claim 53, wherein at least one thiol-containing amino acid is substituted at a position corresponding to position 51, 52, 56, 75, 90, 76, 81, 105, 116, 132, 135, 138, 168, 177, 189 and 195, and any combination thereof, and wherein the protein is modified by attachment to a maleimide-linked moiety.
 55. The isolated protein of claim 54, wherein the thiol-containing amino acid is cysteine or methionine.
 56. The isolated protein of claim 54, wherein the maleimide-linked moiety is a polyethylene glycol (PEG) moiety. 